Monday 14 November 2011

History of Western Philosophy - Notes on Descartes, Spinoza and Leibniz

Rene Descartes (1596-1650)
  • Founder of modern philosophy - Outlook altered by new physics and astromony
  • Didn't publish book - two strange doctrines about the earth's rotation and infinite universe
  • Philosopher, mathematician, man of science
  • Geometry
  • Co-ordinates
  • Regarded bodies of men and animals as 'machines'.
    • Animals controlled by physics, devoid of feeling/conciousness
    • Men have souls which reside in the pineal gland, contact with vital spirits
  • Mechanics
    • Accepts first law of motion
    • No vacuum, no atoms, just nature of impact
  • Says world created in Genesis BUT:
    • Thinks it could be natural
    • Theory of formation of vortices: around sun immense vortex in plenum which carries planets
  • Discourse on Method (1637) & Meditations (1642)
    • Method of 'Cartisan Doubt' - Doubting everything to clear mind
      • Scepticism
      • Dreams give us copies of real things
  • Theory of Knowledge
    • 'I think, therefore I am' - mind more certain than matter
  • Questions knowledge of our bodies
    • Things can change when burnt etc - smell, taste different
      • "I understand by the sole power of judgement, which resides in my mind, what I thought I saw with my eyes." - You don't know if what you're seeing is true, you can only think it
  • Errors
    • To think that ideas are  like outside things
    • Three sorts of ideas
      • Innate
      • foreign and come from without
      • Invented by me
  • Method of critical doubt
    • Indubitle facts
      • own thoughts
      • Thoughts are more certain than external objects
    • Indubitable principles of inference
Spinoza (1632-1677)
  • Book: Ethics
    • Metaphysics: Parimenides, One substance 'god or nature'
    • Thought and extension both attributes of god
    • No free will, everything is controlled by god
      • leads to problems with sin
      • Spinoza argued back that negation is only in the eye of the finite beholder, not the infinite god
    • Theory of emotions
      • Passions distract us and obstruct us from our intellectual vision of the whole
      • Hatred can be increased when recipricated but destroyed by love
    • All wrong actions are due to error - like Socrates and Plato
      • self-seeking/preservation governs behaviour
    • Time is unreal
      • Disasters in our time are considered worse than those in the past
      • Spinoza says time should be irrelevant and that a disaster then is a disaster now.
      • Events are part of god's eternal, timeless world as he sees it. God sees the date as irrelevant
    • The theory of evil is an inadequate knowledge - God has no knowledge of evil, everything is his good-doing
    • Does not object to all emotions, only those that are passions
    • God is not affected by emotions or pleasure or pain
      • He who loves god should not expect love in return
    • Logical monoism
      • The world only exists because everything exists together. Not one bit could exist without the rest
  • Political theory derived from Hobbes
    • Disagrees that all rights should be submitted to sovereign and that democracy is 'most natural' form of government
Leibniz Thanks to - Tom Baxter
  • Substances
    •  Extension is the centre of matter 
    •  Extension isn't an attribute of a substance - extension is an attribute of plurality (more than one) so can't be linked to just one substance. Each single substance becomes more than one once extended. 
  • Arguments for existence of god
    •  Ontological argument: Existence vs Essence, God is the greatest thing imaginable, it is greater to exist than not to exist, God exists
    •  Cosmological Argument: Every finite has a cause and a meaning, a casual loop can't exist, a casual chain can't be an infinite length, a cause and an effect must exist
    • The Argument for Eternal Truths: Statements can be either true or false, those that are always true (such as numbers) are the eternal truths
    • The Argument for Pre-Established Harmony: All clocks keep time with each other without interacting, if there's no interaction how do the others know they exist? 

No comments:

Post a Comment